• Get 30% Off with code "NOV"
  • 40% OFF GROWTH ACCOUNTS
  • ENDS 13 NOVEMBER, 11:59PM EST

In the Money vs Out of the Money Options

A laptop chart with price on both sides of a single level, under the headline In the Money vs Out of the Money Options.

TL;DR: In the money vs out of the money options differ by strike vs price: a call is ITM with price above its strike, a put with price below it. Only ITM options hold intrinsic value, and ATM or OTM premiums are pure time value that decays. With a stock at $100 in an illustrative model, a 95 call costs $6.65 and a 105 call $1.66, but the 105 needs a 6.7% rally to break even. ITM is a location, not a profit, so check strike plus premium first.

You open an options chain and see two calls on the same stock, same expiration. One costs $6.65. The other costs $1.66. The cheap one looks like the better deal, and that is exactly where a lot of newer traders get caught.

The difference between those two prices is mostly about moneyness: whether the option is in the money (ITM), at the money (ATM) or out of the money (OTM). Moneyness tells you where the strike sits against the current price of the underlying. It does not tell you whether the trade will make money.

So treat moneyness as two separate checks. First, where is the strike against the price right now? Second, how far does the price have to travel, and how fast, to cover the premium you paid? Most expensive mistakes with options come from answering the first question and skipping the second. Every example here uses a hypothetical stock and model prices labelled as illustrative, not live quotes.

Call, Put, Strike and Premium Basics for Options

Options moneyness only makes sense once the parts of an option contract are clear. An option is a contract that gives its owner the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell an underlying asset at a fixed price on or before a set date. The SEC's investor bulletin on options lists stocks, stock indexes, exchange-traded funds and fixed income products among the possible underlying assets.

The pieces that matter for moneyness:

  • Call option. The right to buy the underlying at the strike price.
  • Put option. The right to sell the underlying at the strike price.
  • Strike price. The fixed price at which the holder can buy (call) or sell (put).
  • Premium. The price the buyer pays the seller up front. It is quoted per share and is not refundable.
  • Expiration. The last day the contract exists. After it passes, the right is gone.
  • Contract size. A listed stock option generally covers 100 shares, so a $2.20 premium costs $220 per contract.

Two sides exist on every option. The buyer (holder) pays the premium and gets the right. The seller (writer) collects the premium and takes on the obligation to deliver or buy the shares if the holder exercises.

Moneyness is a label for the holder's right. It answers one question: if the holder used that right this second, would it be worth anything?

In the Money vs Out of the Money Options Defined

Option moneyness by strike: a strike at the stock price is at the money, strikes above it are out of the money for calls and in the money for puts, and strikes below are the reverse.

An in-the-money option is a contract whose right is worth something if used immediately. An out-of-the-money option is a contract whose right is worth nothing if used immediately. An at-the-money option sits right on the line, with a strike equal to the current price of the underlying.

The Options Industry Council (OIC) and the SEC use the same definitions:

  • A call is ITM when the strike is below the stock price. You could buy for less than the market price.
  • A call is OTM when the strike is above the stock price. Buying at the strike would cost more than buying in the market.
  • A put is ITM when the strike is above the stock price. You could sell for more than the market pays.
  • A put is OTM when the strike is below the stock price. Selling at the strike would bring in less than the market.
  • ATM means the strike and the stock price are the same, for calls and puts alike.

The SEC bulletin gives a simple example. An ABC December 70 call with ABC stock at $80 is in the money by $10, because the holder can buy at $70 shares worth $80. With the stock at $60, the same call is out of the money by $10.

What an in the money option does not mean

If your option is in the money, it means the contract has intrinsic value right now. It does not mean your position shows a profit.

Profit depends on what you paid. An ITM call bought for more than its intrinsic value can be in the money and still show a loss, especially close to expiration when the extra premium has mostly bled away. That gap between "in the money" and "profitable" is the single most useful thing to understand about options moneyness.

How the Strike Price Sets an Option's Moneyness

The strike price is the fixed half of the moneyness comparison. The underlying price is the moving half. Moneyness is whatever relationship those two numbers have at the moment you look.

That means the label belongs to the moment, not the contract. A 105 call on a stock at $100 is OTM by $5 in the morning. If the stock rallies to $105 it is ATM, and at $108 it is ITM by $3. Nothing about the contract changed. The price moved past a fixed strike.

Depth of moneyness

Traders also describe how far an option sits from the line:

  • Deep in the money. The strike is far from the price on the favorable side. The option behaves much like the underlying itself, and most of its premium is intrinsic value.
  • Slightly in the money or near the money. One or two strikes from the price. The option has some intrinsic value and a meaningful slice of time value.
  • Far out of the money. The strike is a long way from the price on the unfavorable side. The option is cheap and needs a large move to be worth anything at expiration.

There is no official cut-off for "deep" or "far". Distance only means something relative to how much the underlying normally moves in the time left. A $5 gap is huge on a sleepy stock with a week left and small on a volatile stock with three months left.

Measuring distance from the strike

The arithmetic is simple. For a call, subtract the strike from the underlying price. For a put, subtract the underlying price from the strike. A positive answer is the amount ITM. A negative answer is how far OTM the option is.

Suppose a stock trades at $101.20 and the chain lists 100 and 105 strikes. The 100 call is ITM by $1.20. The 105 call is OTM by $3.80. The 105 put is ITM by $3.80, and the 100 put is OTM by $1.20.

Related lesson: How strike prices work

Call Options vs Put Options Moneyness

Call and put moneyness run in opposite directions, and that reversal is where most labelling mistakes start. A call gains moneyness as the underlying rises. A put gains moneyness as the underlying falls.

The table shows one stock at $100 (illustrative) and three strikes:

Strike Call status Put status
95 ITM by $5 OTM by $5
100 ATM ATM
105 OTM by $5 ITM by $5

Read the table across a row and you see the mirror. The strike that is ITM for a call is OTM for a put, and the reverse.

A plain-English check for calls and puts

When the labels blur, say the right out loud:

  • "A 95 call is the right to buy at $95." With the stock at $100, that right is worth $5 now. ITM.
  • "A 95 put is the right to sell at $95." With the stock at $100, nobody would sell below market. OTM.

Calls and puts on the same strike and expiration can both be ATM at once, but they can never both be ITM. Whenever the price sits off the strike, one side has intrinsic value and the other does not.

At the Money Options and the Nearest Strike

An at-the-money option has a strike equal to the current underlying price. Strictly, that is rare, because prices move in cents while strikes are listed at fixed intervals. In practice, traders call the strike closest to the current price the ATM strike.

With the stock at $101.20, the 100 strike is technically ITM for the call by $1.20, but most traders would still call it the at-the-money strike. When you read someone else's analysis, check which meaning they use.

Why ATM options matter

At-the-money options sit at the point of greatest uncertainty. The stock could finish on either side of the strike, so the option has no intrinsic value but the most time value on the chain.

In an illustrative model (stock at $100, 30 days to expiration, 30% implied volatility), the 100 call prices at $3.59 and the 100 put at $3.26. Every cent of both premiums is time value. The OIC's delta guide notes that ATM call deltas stay around .50 as expiration nears, which means the option's price moves roughly half as much as the stock for a small move. The same model gives the 100 call a delta of 0.53.

That makes ATM the hinge of the chain. Strikes on one side gain intrinsic value and delta. Strikes on the other side lose both.

Intrinsic Value of In the Money Options

Intrinsic value is the amount an option is in the money. Only ITM options have it. ATM and OTM options have an intrinsic value of zero.

The formulas:

  • Call intrinsic value = the greater of zero or (underlying price minus strike).
  • Put intrinsic value = the greater of zero or (strike minus underlying price).

The "greater of zero" part is important. Intrinsic value can never be negative, because the holder is never forced to use a right that would lose money. If the formula would give a negative number, the option is OTM and its intrinsic value is simply zero.

Worked intrinsic value examples

With an illustrative stock at $100:

  • The 90 call has $10.00 of intrinsic value ($100 minus $90).
  • The 95 call has $5.00.
  • The 105 put has $5.00 ($105 minus $100).
  • The 110 put has $10.00.
  • The 105 call and 95 put have none.

Per contract, multiply by 100. The 95 call's $5.00 of intrinsic value is $500 of built-in exercise value per contract.

Why intrinsic value is the floor at expiration

At expiration, time value is gone and an ITM option is generally worth its intrinsic value, according to the OIC. Before expiration, an ITM option almost always trades for more than intrinsic value, because the remaining time still has worth.

The OIC gives a clean example. A stock at $32.80 with a $32.50 call priced at $1.10 two weeks before expiration. The call is ITM by $0.30, so time value is $0.80. Exercising that call and selling the stock captures $0.30. Selling the call captures $1.10. Exercising early throws away the $0.80 of time value, which is one reason holders usually sell instead.

Time Value in Option Premiums

An in-the-money option premium holds intrinsic value plus time value, while an at-the-money or out-of-the-money premium is all time value, which decays toward expiration.

Time value, also called extrinsic value, is everything in an option's premium beyond intrinsic value. ATM and OTM options are made entirely of time value. ITM options are intrinsic value plus time value.

The OIC lists what drives it: time left until expiration, volatility, interest rates and dividends. More time and more expected movement mean a higher chance the option ends up ITM, so buyers pay more for that chance.

How option time value decays

Time value shrinks as expiration approaches, all else equal. The OIC notes that decay increases rapidly in the last several weeks of an option's life.

The illustrative model shows the shape. The stock stays at $100 and only the days to expiration change:

Days to expiration 95 call (ITM) price 95 call time value 100 call (ATM) price 105 call (OTM) price
90 $9.21 $4.21 $6.41 $4.28
60 $8.05 $3.05 $5.17 $3.09
30 $6.65 $1.65 $3.59 $1.66
14 $5.72 $0.72 $2.42 $0.72
7 $5.28 $0.28 $1.70 $0.26
1 $5.01 $0.01 $0.63 $0.00

Three patterns stand out.

The ITM call never falls below its $5.00 of intrinsic value. Its time value melts, but the floor holds as long as the stock stays at $100.

The ATM call holds the most time value at every point, and it loses value fastest near the end. It sheds $1.17 between 30 and 14 days, then another $1.07 in the final week from 7 days to 1 day.

The OTM call goes to zero. With the stock flat, the 105 call is worth $1.66 a month out and nothing the day before expiration. Time is the OTM buyer's biggest opponent.

Why OTM Options Need Direction and Timing

A directional view can be right and still lose if it arrives late. The OIC's long-call guide puts it plainly: being right about a rally does no good if it happens after expiration. Every long option is a bet on direction and timing together, and OTM options carry the most timing risk because they hold nothing but time value.

Related lesson: Intrinsic value and time value in option premiums

ITM vs OTM Option Prices Compared

ITM options cost more than OTM options on the same underlying and expiration because they contain intrinsic value. OTM options are cheaper because they contain only time value, and that time value shrinks the further the strike sits from the price.

The model chain uses a hypothetical stock at $100, 30 days to expiration, 30% implied volatility and a 4% interest rate. These are illustrative Black-Scholes prices, not market quotes.

Strike Call price Call intrinsic Call time value Call delta Put price Put intrinsic Put time value Put delta
90 $10.70 $10.00 $0.70 0.90 $0.40 $0.00 $0.40 -0.10
95 $6.65 $5.00 $1.65 0.75 $1.33 $0.00 $1.33 -0.25
100 $3.59 $0.00 $3.59 0.53 $3.26 $0.00 $3.26 -0.47
105 $1.66 $0.00 $1.66 0.31 $6.32 $5.00 $1.32 -0.69
110 $0.66 $0.00 $0.66 0.15 $10.29 $10.00 $0.29 -0.85

Reading the ITM vs OTM price table

The cheapest options are the deepest OTM ones. The 110 call costs $0.66 and the 90 put costs $0.40. They are cheap because they need the largest move to be worth anything.

Time value peaks at the money. Move a strike in either direction and time value falls. Deep ITM options carry little time value because most of their price is intrinsic. Far OTM options carry little because the market prices a low chance of them finishing ITM.

Delta tracks moneyness. The deep ITM 90 call has a delta of 0.90, so it moves almost dollar for dollar with the stock. The far OTM 110 call has a delta of 0.15 and barely reacts to a $1 move. The OIC treats an option under .10 delta as unlikely to finish ITM.

Per contract, the 95 call costs $665 and the 105 call costs $166. The cheaper contract is not better value. It is a different bet: smaller cost, larger required move.

In the Money Options Benefits and Risks

Buying in-the-money options appeals to traders who want an option to act more like the underlying. The tradeoff is cost.

Benefits of ITM options

  • Higher delta. The 95 call's delta of 0.75 means it tracks the stock more closely than an ATM or OTM call.
  • Less time value at risk. Of the 95 call's $6.65 premium, only $1.65 is time value. If the stock goes nowhere, decay eats less of the position.
  • Closer break-even. The 95 call breaks even at expiration at $101.65, only $1.65 above the current price. The 105 call needs $106.66.
  • Some value even when the stock drifts a little the wrong way. A small dip still leaves the 95 call with intrinsic value as long as the stock stays above $95.

Risks of ITM options

  • More money at risk per contract. The 95 call costs $665 per contract against $166 for the 105 call. The maximum loss for a buyer is the full premium, and a larger premium is a larger possible loss.
  • Smaller percentage gains. If the stock finishes at $110, the 95 call returns about 126% and the 105 call about 201%.
  • A false sense of safety. ITM still loses the full premium if the stock falls through the strike before expiration. "In the money" is not a protected position.
  • Wider spreads on deep strikes. Deep ITM strikes often trade less than strikes near the money, so check the bid-ask spread before entering.

ITM options suit a trader who has a directional view, wants high delta and accepts a larger premium in exchange for a smaller required move. The question to ask is not "is this safer" but "can I afford to lose this whole premium if the stock breaks the other way".

Out of the Money Options Benefits and Risks

Out-of-the-money options are popular because they are cheap. The cheap price comes from a real cost: the option needs the underlying to move far enough, soon enough.

How OTM options make money

An OTM option can make money in two ways.

  • Before expiration, its premium rises. A move toward the strike, a jump in implied volatility, or both can lift the premium. The holder sells the option for more than they paid without the option ever becoming ITM.
  • At expiration, it finishes ITM beyond break-even. The underlying moves past the strike by more than the premium paid. The 105 call bought at $1.66 needs the stock above $106.66 at expiration to profit.

Most holders take the first route. The OIC reports that in about 70% of options trades the holder sells to close rather than exercising.

Benefits of OTM options

  • Low cost per contract. The 105 call costs $166 against $665 for the 95 call.
  • Defined loss for buyers. A long OTM option can lose no more than its premium.
  • Large percentage gains if the move arrives. At a $115 finish, the 105 call returns about 502% against 201% for the 95 call.

Risks of OTM options

  • More ways to lose the whole premium. With the stock at $100, $105 or anywhere below $105 at expiration, the 105 call expires worthless.
  • All time value. In the illustrative model, a 105 call worth $1.66 with 30 days left falls to zero by the final day if the stock sits at $100.
  • Low delta. A 0.31 delta means a $1 rally adds only about $0.31 to the premium at first.
  • The temptation to buy more. A low price per contract makes it easy to buy several and quietly risk more total dollars than an ITM trade would.

OTM options suit a trader who expects a large move within a known window, such as a scheduled earnings date, and has sized the trade so losing the full premium is acceptable. If the plan only works because the contract is cheap, it is not a plan yet.

What Happens to ITM and OTM Options at Expiration

At expiration, out-of-the-money and at-the-money options generally expire worthless, while in-the-money options are worth their intrinsic value.

At expiration, an option's time value is gone and only moneyness remains. That makes expiration the moment the label finally decides the outcome.

  • OTM at expiration. The option expires worthless. The holder loses the full premium, and the writer keeps it.
  • ATM at expiration. The option has no intrinsic value and generally expires worthless too.
  • ITM at expiration. The option is worth its intrinsic value. The holder can sell it before the close or let it be exercised.

Automatic exercise of ITM options

The Options Clearing Corporation uses a procedure called exercise by exception. Expiring equity and index options that are $0.01 or more in the money are exercised unless contrary instructions are given. Brokers can use their own thresholds, and the OIC urges holders to give explicit instructions on any expiring option.

That matters because an ITM stock call that gets exercised turns into a purchase of 100 shares per contract. A trader who did not set aside the cash can face an urgent funding problem. The OIC's long-call guide flags this exact risk.

Expiration profit and loss for three calls

The table uses the illustrative 30-day model prices. Each figure is per contract (100 shares), before fees.

Stock at expiration 95 call (paid $665) 100 call (paid $359) 105 call (paid $166)
$95 -$665 (-100%) -$359 (-100%) -$166 (-100%)
$100 -$165 (-25%) -$359 (-100%) -$166 (-100%)
$105 +$335 (+50%) +$141 (+39%) -$166 (-100%)
$110 +$835 (+126%) +$641 (+179%) +$334 (+201%)
$115 +$1,335 (+201%) +$1,141 (+318%) +$834 (+502%)

Look at the $100 row. The 95 call finishes ITM by $5 and still loses $165, because its $665 cost included $165 of time value. In the money did not mean profitable.

Look at the $105 row. The stock rose 5%, which sounds like a win for a call buyer. The 105 call still lost everything, because it finished exactly at the money. The direction was right. The trade was still wrong, because the strike asked for more than the market delivered.

Option Moneyness Risk for Buyers and Sellers

Moneyness affects buyers and sellers in opposite ways. The buyer wants the option to move ITM. The writer wants it to stay OTM and expire worthless.

Option buyer risk

A buyer's maximum loss is the premium paid, according to the OIC. An OTM purchase risks a smaller dollar amount with a higher chance of losing all of it. An ITM purchase risks a larger dollar amount with a lower chance of a total loss.

Option seller risk

A writer collects the premium and takes on the obligation. If the option moves ITM, the writer can be assigned:

  • Short call. The writer must deliver shares at the strike. The OIC describes the potential loss on an uncovered short call as theoretically unlimited, since a stock has no price ceiling.
  • Short put. The writer must buy shares at the strike. Loss is limited because a stock cannot fall below $0, but it can still be very large.

FINRA notes that short positions in American-style options can be assigned on any day the equity markets are open, not just at expiration. It also notes that only about 7% of options positions are typically exercised, which does not mean a writer will be assigned on only 7% of positions.

FINRA gives a sharp example. A trader sells 10 XYZ July 50 calls at $1.00 with the stock at $40, collecting $1,000. The stock jumps to $60 and the calls are assigned. Delivering 1,000 shares at $50 that are worth $60 leaves an unrealized loss of $9,000 after the premium. The OTM option that looked like easy income became a deep ITM obligation.

Moneyness from each side

Moneyness Buyer's position Writer's position
Far OTM Cheap, high chance of total loss Small premium, low chance of assignment
ATM Most time value, coin-flip location Most premium collected, highest decay benefit
Deep ITM Expensive, acts like the underlying Likely assignment, large obligation

Related lesson: Options assignment risk

How to Choose Between ITM and OTM Options

There is no universally better choice between ITM and OTM options. The right strike follows from what the trade needs: how far the underlying must move, how fast, and how much premium you can lose.

Is it better to buy ITM or OTM calls

Buying ITM calls is usually the choice when you expect a moderate move and want the option to track the stock closely. Buying OTM calls is the choice when you expect a large, fast move and accept a high chance of losing the full premium. Neither is safer in every case.

One ITM Call vs Four OTM Calls on the Same Budget

Equal dollar risk makes the comparison honest. With the illustrative prices, about $665 buys one 95 call or four 105 calls ($664).

Stock at expiration One 95 call Four 105 calls
$95 -$665 -$664
$105 +$335 -$664
$110 +$835 +$1,336
$115 +$1,335 +$3,336

The ITM trade wins on a moderate move. The OTM trade wins on a big move and loses everything on anything less than about a 6.7% rally. Same budget, completely different shape.

A strike selection checklist for options moneyness

Before choosing a strike, write down:

  • The price the underlying needs to reach, and by when.
  • The expiration break-even for each strike you are considering (strike plus premium for calls, strike minus premium for puts).
  • How much of each premium is time value, and how much that time value could decay before your target date.
  • The total dollars at risk, not just the price per contract.
  • The bid-ask spread and volume on each strike.
  • What price action, or what date, tells you the idea is wrong.

If you cannot answer the last line, the strike decision is not finished. The cheapest strike only looks attractive until you write down what has to happen for it to pay. Missing a move also does not make the next strike out a good entry. It is a different trade with a different break-even.

Common Option Moneyness Mistakes

Most option moneyness mistakes come from reading the label and skipping the math behind it. Each one has a simple check that catches it.

Treating ITM as a profit label

An option can be ITM while the holder is losing money, because the premium paid included time value. Always compare the option's current value with what you paid, not just the strike with the price.

Treating OTM as cheap

A low premium is not a discount. It reflects a lower chance of finishing ITM. Four cheap contracts can put more dollars at risk than one expensive one.

Forgetting the clock

A move that arrives after expiration pays nothing. In the illustrative model, an OTM 105 call on a flat $100 stock drops from $1.66 with 30 days left to $0.26 with a week left. Being right next month does not help an option that expires this month.

Reversing calls and puts

Calls are ITM below the price; puts are ITM above it. If the labels blur, restate the right: a call is the right to buy, a put is the right to sell.

Exercising early and forfeiting time value

Exercising an ITM option before expiration captures only intrinsic value. Selling the option usually captures intrinsic value plus whatever time value remains.

Forgetting automatic exercise

An ITM option held into expiration may be exercised for you under exercise by exception, creating a stock position you did not plan for. Close it or give your broker explicit instructions.

Options Moneyness on Futures Contracts

Options moneyness also matters to traders who never buy an option. Options are listed on many futures contracts as well as on stocks, and FINRA notes that most options on commodity and index futures in U.S. markets are European-style. The ITM, ATM and OTM definitions work the same way on those contracts: compare the strike with the price of the underlying futures contract.

For a futures trader, the useful habit is the two-threshold check itself. Where is price now, and what has to happen, by when, for the idea to pay? That question applies to a futures entry as much as to an option strike.

On our accounts, you trade CME futures such as ES, NQ, YM, RTY and their micros. We do not offer options, cash stocks, forex or single stock futures, so moneyness is background knowledge for reading the market rather than something you trade with us. Our funded accounts are simulated, and every position is closed by 4:45 PM ET each trading day.

In the Money vs Out of the Money Options FAQ

What does it mean if your option is in the money

It means the option has intrinsic value right now. A call is ITM when the stock trades above the strike, and a put is ITM when the stock trades below the strike. It does not mean your position is profitable, because the premium you paid may be higher than that intrinsic value.

What did Warren Buffett say about options

In his 2002 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, Warren Buffett called derivatives "financial weapons of mass destruction". Berkshire still sold long-dated put contracts on stock indexes, some due in 15 years and others in 20, as his 2008 letter explains. That letter also argued the Black-Scholes pricing formula can produce absurd results over very long periods.

Can an out of the money option become in the money

Yes. A call moves ITM if the underlying rises above its strike, and a put moves ITM if the underlying falls below its strike. The move has to happen before expiration to matter.

Do out of the money options have any value

Before expiration, yes. An OTM option has no intrinsic value, but its time value reflects the chance it finishes ITM. At expiration, an OTM option is worthless.

Is moneyness the same as delta

No. Moneyness compares the strike with the underlying price. Delta estimates how much the option's price changes for a $1 move in the underlying. Delta rises as a call moves deeper ITM, so the two are linked, but they measure different things.

What happens if I hold an ITM option to expiration

Under the clearinghouse's exercise by exception procedure, an expiring option $0.01 or more in the money is exercised unless instructions say otherwise. For a stock call, that means buying 100 shares per contract. Many holders sell the option before expiration to avoid that.

The Bottom Line on Option Moneyness

Moneyness is a location, not a result. A call is ITM when the price sits above the strike, a put is ITM when the price sits below it, and ATM sits on the line. Only ITM options carry intrinsic value; everything else in a premium is time value that decays.

The useful habit is two checks on every strike. First, where is the strike against the price right now? Second, where is the break-even, and can the move reach it before expiration? Run both on a few strikes of a real chain, with the dollars at risk written next to each, before deciding that the cheap option is the better one.

Options involve substantial risk and are not suitable for every investor. A purchased option can lose its entire premium, and some short option positions can lose far more than the premium received. Futures and other leveraged products can also produce losses larger than expected. Simulated and funded accounts are simulated trading conditions that can differ from live markets. All prices in this article are hypothetical model values for education, exclude fees and commissions, and are not investment advice.