• Get 30% Off with code "NOV"
  • 40% OFF GROWTH ACCOUNTS
  • ENDS 13 NOVEMBER, 11:59PM EST

Marubozu and Spinning Top Candles Explained

Overhead view of a trader's desk with a candlestick chart on a tablet, under the headline Marubozu and Spinning Top Candles Explained.

TL;DR: Marubozu and spinning top candles sit at opposite ends of one measurement: how much of a bar's range the body fills. A marubozu is nearly all body, so one side controlled the whole bar; a spinning top is a small body with two shadows. Neither predicts the next bar well, so fix your shadow rules first and price the stop before you trade either one. On a marubozu, a pullback entry often pays better than the breakout. A spinning top bracket breakout pays under 1 to 1, so treat it as a level.

What Marubozu and Spinning Top Candles Say About Buyers and Sellers

Marubozu and spinning top candles are single-bar patterns, and they describe the same thing from opposite ends: how much of the bar's high-to-low range turned into net progress from open to close.

A marubozu is a candle with a long body and no shadows, or shadows so small they barely register. The name is Japanese and is usually translated as "close-cropped head" or "bald hill", which describes the look: a block with nothing sticking out of either end. A bullish marubozu opens at the low and closes at the high. A bearish marubozu opens at the high and closes at the low.

What it records is control. Buyers (on a bullish bar) or sellers (on a bearish bar) moved price in one direction from the first trade to the last, and the other side never pushed it back far enough to leave a shadow. That is why many traders read it as momentum, and why it is so tempting to chase.

A spinning top is a candle with a small body and shadows above and below it. Price travelled up, travelled down, and closed not far from where it opened. What it records is a standoff. Both sides had a turn and neither finished the bar in control, which is why it is usually called an indecision candle.

Here is where traders get caught. Each candle describes the bar that just closed, not the next one. A marubozu says one side held control for that bar. It does not say that side keeps control. A spinning top says nobody won that bar. It does not say a reversal is coming. The trading value comes from where the candle prints and how you plan the entry and stop.

Marubozu Types and Spinning Top Structure

A marubozu is nearly all body with no shadows, showing one side controlled the bar, while a spinning top has a small central body and two long, balanced shadows.

Marubozu candles come in three structural variants in each direction, depending on which end of the bar still carries a shadow. Academic studies of candlesticks, including the 2017 SET50 study by Tharavanij, Siraprapasiri and Rajchamaha, define them with exact price equalities.

Marubozu variant Price condition What the shadow tells you
White (bullish) marubozu High equals close, open equals low No shadow at either end, buyers controlled the whole bar
Closing white marubozu High equals close, open above low Buyers closed at the high after an early dip below the open
Opening white marubozu Open equals low, high above close Buyers held the open as the low but gave back some of the high
Black (bearish) marubozu Open equals high, close equals low No shadow at either end, sellers controlled the whole bar
Closing black marubozu Close equals low, high above open Sellers closed at the low after an early push above the open
Opening black marubozu Open equals high, close above low Sellers held the open as the high but buyers took back some of the low

The SET50 study lists the closing variants ahead of the opening ones in its ordering by signal strength, and the logic is easy to follow. A closing marubozu finished at its extreme. An opening marubozu finished away from it, so the side in control gave back a little ground in the last part of the bar.

A spinning top's structure is about where the small body sits. The classic shape has the body near the middle of the range, with an upper and lower shadow that are each longer than the body and roughly similar in length. The body can be white or black, green or red.

A high wave spinning top is the stretched version: a small body with unusually long shadows on both sides. It is the candle sometimes called a "wave candle". It records the same standoff with more violence, because price travelled much further in both directions before ending up near the open.

How to Identify a Marubozu or Spinning Top With a Range Test

The hard part of identifying either candle is that most definitions say "small" or "no" shadows without a number. Real bars rarely give you a perfect zero, so two traders can look at one candle and disagree. The fix is to measure each part of the candle as a percentage of the bar's own range, then write the cutoffs down before the session.

Measuring in percentage of range matters because points mislead. A 0.50 point shadow is nothing on a 36.00 point bar and a large share of a 4.00 point bar.

These are the working cutoffs used in this guide. They are conventions chosen to make the test repeatable, not published standards:

  • Marubozu: both shadows at or under a fixed tolerance. This guide tests 0%, 1% and 2% of range.
  • Spinning top: body at or under 30% of range, each shadow at least 20% of range, and the two shadows within 15 percentage points of each other.
  • Doji first: any body under 5% of range goes to the doji family before the spinning top test runs.

Six candles run through the marubozu and spinning top test

The six illustrative E-mini S&P 500 bars in this table use round prices, not real quotes, and are tested against the cutoffs listed for this range test.

Bar Open, high, low, close Body share of range Upper shadow share Lower shadow share Verdict at 0% tolerance Verdict at 1% tolerance Verdict at 2% tolerance
C1 7,000.00, 7,036.00, 7,000.00, 7,036.00 100.00% 0.00% 0.00% Bullish marubozu Bullish marubozu Bullish marubozu
C2 7,000.00, 7,036.25, 6,999.75, 7,035.75 97.95% 1.37% 0.68% Not a marubozu Not a marubozu Bullish marubozu
C3 7,016.50, 7,034.00, 7,000.00, 7,014.00 7.35% 51.47% 41.18% Spinning top Spinning top Spinning top
C4 7,018.00, 7,034.00, 7,002.00, 7,018.25 0.78% 49.22% 50.00% Doji family Doji family Doji family
C5 7,022.00, 7,028.00, 7,004.00, 7,024.50 10.42% 14.58% 75.00% Rejection candle Rejection candle Rejection candle
C6 7,009.25, 7,020.00, 7,003.50, 7,016.50 43.94% 21.21% 34.85% Ordinary candle Ordinary candle Ordinary candle

C1 is the textbook marubozu: a 36.00 point range with a body that fills all of it. C2 is the bar that causes arguments. It has a 0.50 point upper shadow and a 0.25 point lower shadow, worth 1.37% and 0.68% of its 36.50 point range. It fails at 0% and at 1%, and it passes at 2%. Nothing about the bar changed. Only the rule did.

That is the reason to fix the tolerance before you look at the chart. A rule you loosen after seeing a bar you like is not a rule. It is a justification.

C3 passes the spinning top test: a 7.35% body, shadows of 51.47% and 41.18%, and a gap of 10.29 percentage points between them. C4 has a 0.78% body, so it is a doji, not a spinning top. C5 has a small 10.42% body, but its shadows are 14.58% and 75.00%, so one side did all the rejecting. That is a hammer-style rejection candle, not a standoff. C6 has a 43.94% body, too large for either pattern.

Candle Color and Direction on a Marubozu or Spinning Top

Candle color on both patterns tells you which side finished ahead, but it matters far more on a marubozu than on a spinning top.

On a marubozu, color is the whole signal. A white or green marubozu closed at or near its high after opening at or near its low, so buyers drove the bar. A black or red marubozu is the mirror. Color plus the preceding move tells you whether that control is a continuation (a green marubozu inside an uptrend) or an interruption (a green marubozu after a decline).

Even so, the follow-through is modest. Thomas Bulkowski's published candlestick statistics at ThePatternSite record the white marubozu acting as a continuation 56% of the time and the black marubozu 53% of the time. He calls results in that range "near random".

On a spinning top, color barely matters. The body is small by definition, so a green spinning top and a red one might differ by a tick or two. The meaningful information is the two-way travel, not which side squeaked out the close. Bulkowski's figures fit this: the white spinning top reversed 50% of the time and the black spinning top 51% of the time.

A red candle on its own is bearish for that bar only, because it closed below its open. Whether it matters depends on its shape and location. A red marubozu at a support level is a strong statement by sellers. A red spinning top at that level is a shrug.

Spinning Top vs Doji, Hammer and High Wave Candles

How a spinning top differs from a doji, a hammer and a high wave candle by body size and shadow balance.

The spinning top gets confused with several neighbours, and each mix-up leads to a different, usually wrong, trade plan. The marubozu has fewer look-alikes but still gets mixed up with ordinary long candles.

Candle Body Shadows What it records
Marubozu Nearly the whole range None or tiny on both ends One side controlled the bar
Long candle Large but not the whole range Visible on one or both ends Strong net move with some pushback
Spinning top Small, roughly 5% to 30% of range Both long and roughly balanced Two-way travel, close near the open
High wave spinning top Small Both unusually long Wider two-way travel, same standoff
Doji Under about 5% of range Any Open and close essentially equal
Hammer or shooting star Small One long, one short One side was rejected hard

The doji comparison is the one most traders blur. A doji's open and close are equal or nearly equal, so the bar has no real body at all. A spinning top has a small but real body. In practice, the cleanest rule is to send anything under about 5% of range to the doji family first, so a bar with a 0.78% body is a doji even if it looks like a spinning top.

The hammer comparison matters because it changes the trade. A hammer or shooting star has one long shadow doing all the work, which records a rejection of one side. A spinning top has two balanced shadows, which records no winner. If you treat a rejection candle as a spinning top, you throw away the one piece of directional information the bar gave you.

The long candle comparison matters for the marubozu. A big green bar with a visible upper shadow is a long white candle, not a marubozu, under a strict rule. The shadow tells you sellers pushed back before the close.

Related lesson: Doji candlestick patterns

Confluence That Gives a Marubozu or Spinning Top Meaning

A marubozu or spinning top in the middle of nowhere is just a bar. Location and context are what turn either one into something worth planning around.

The factors that do most of the work:

  • Trend context. A marubozu in the direction of an established trend reads as continuation. A marubozu against the trend, especially the first one after a long move, reads as a possible shift. A spinning top after a long run reads as the trend losing pace, and the same candle inside a tight range means very little.
  • Support and resistance. A spinning top that prints at a known level tells you the level is being contested. A marubozu that closes through a level tells you one side broke it with conviction.
  • Bar size relative to recent bars. A marubozu that is far taller than the bars around it is a bigger statement than a small marubozu in a quiet stretch. A small marubozu on a short intraday bar can be little more than tick rounding.
  • Volume. A marubozu on heavy volume shows participation behind the move. A spinning top on heavy volume shows a real fight at that price, not just a quiet bar.
  • Position in the larger range. Bulkowski's notes from his candlestick encyclopedia say white marubozu candles within a third of the yearly low performed best, and white spinning tops within a third of the yearly low also performed best.

Indicator filters are less helpful than they sound. The 2017 SET50 study found that filtering candlestick signals with stochastics, RSI or the money flow index generally did not improve profitability or prediction accuracy. A filter earns its place by removing failures in your own records, not by making the chart look more thorough.

Related lesson: Support and resistance

Marubozu and Spinning Top Trading Strategies

Marubozu and spinning top candles fit four strategy approaches. Each one uses the candle for a different job, and mixing them up is how traders end up with entries that do not match their stops.

  • Marubozu pullback continuation. After a marubozu in the trend direction, wait for price to pull back into the bar, often around its midpoint, and buy (or sell, on a bearish bar) there with the stop beyond the far end of the bar. This uses the marubozu as a zone that one side defended.
  • Marubozu momentum breakout. Enter as price trades beyond the marubozu's close, betting the push continues. It is the most intuitive approach and often the worst priced one, because a stop beyond the bar's far end sits a full bar height away.
  • Spinning top as a level. Mark the spinning top's high and low, and let the next bars decide. A close beyond either end, especially at a support or resistance level, becomes the trigger, and the entry is planned off that level rather than off the spinning top itself.
  • Spinning top reversal at an extreme. After an extended move into a known level, a spinning top can be the first sign the move is losing steam. Traders who use it this way wait for a confirming bar in the opposite direction before entering.

Trend followers tend to use the two marubozu approaches. Range and reversal traders tend to use the two spinning top approaches. Choose one per setup and keep it the same across your sample, so your results describe one rule.

Related lesson: Breakout trading

Entry Rules for Marubozu and Spinning Top Setups

An entry rule for either candle should be written so that two people reading it would place the same order. Each rule needs a trigger, a price, a time limit and a reason to cancel.

For a marubozu pullback entry:

  • The candle passes your written marubozu tolerance.
  • It prints in the trend direction or closes through a level you marked before the session.
  • A limit order rests at the bar's midpoint (or another fixed fraction of the bar you chose in advance).
  • The order cancels if price does not return to it within a set number of bars, or if price closes beyond the bar's far end first.

For a marubozu breakout entry:

  • The candle passes the tolerance and the next bar trades beyond its close.
  • The entry is a stop order a tick or two beyond the marubozu's extreme.
  • The trade is only taken if the stop and target still produce a reward to risk ratio you accept, because a stop beyond the marubozu's far end often makes the breakout pay less than it risks.

For a spinning top level entry:

  • The spinning top passes your three tests (body, shadow floor, shadow balance).
  • It prints at a level that matters, not in the middle of a range.
  • The trigger is a later bar closing beyond the spinning top's high or low. Bulkowski defines a spinning top breakout the same way, as a close above the top or below the bottom of the candle.
  • The entry is planned off that breakout bar, with its own stop and target.

The common thread is that the candle qualifies the setup, and a separate event triggers it. Entering the moment a candle looks right, before anything confirms it, is trading your feelings about the bar. Waiting and getting no trigger is a valid outcome.

Related lesson: Trade setups and confirmation

Stop Loss Placement for Each Candle

A bullish marubozu's stop goes one tick under its low, while a spinning top trade puts the stop beyond the far end of the bar rather than inside its range.

Stop placement for a marubozu or a spinning top is where the two candles stop looking alike. The stop belongs at the price that proves the reading wrong, and each candle has a different one.

For a bullish marubozu, the reading is that buyers controlled the bar. The clean invalidation is a trade below the bar's low, so the standard stop sits one tick under the low. On the E-mini S&P 500 and Micro E-mini S&P 500, one tick is 0.25 index points. A tighter option is a stop under the bar's midpoint, which says buyers should at least defend half the move. A wider option is a stop under a prior swing low, which gives the trade more room and costs more per contract.

For a spinning top, the bar has no single invalidation price inside it, because price already travelled to both ends. A stop placed inside the spinning top's range sits exactly where the bar has just shown it will trade. That is why most plans put the stop beyond the far end of the spinning top, or wait for the breakout bar and place the stop beyond that bar instead.

Stops are orders, not guarantees. A stop market order becomes a market order when it triggers and can fill worse than its price in a fast move.

Related lesson: Stop-loss orders and placement

Profit Targets and the Spinning Top Breakout Problem

A common target for either candle is the measured move: the bar's own height projected from the breakout point. It is simple and repeatable, and on a spinning top it creates a problem that comes straight from the geometry.

Suppose you enter one tick beyond a spinning top's high and place the stop one tick beyond its low. The distance from entry to stop is the bar's range plus two ticks. The measured-move target is the range itself. So the reward is always a little smaller than the risk, whatever size the bar is.

On the E-mini S&P 500 grid of 0.25 points, with a $125 risk budget on Micro E-mini contracts at $5 per index point:

Spinning top range in points Risk in points with one-tick buffers Reward at the measured move Reward to risk Break even win rate Micro E-mini contracts on a $125 budget
6.00 6.50 6.00 0.92 to 1 52.00% 3 contracts, $97.50 at risk
12.00 12.50 12.00 0.96 to 1 51.02% 2 contracts, $125.00 at risk
22.00 22.50 22.00 0.98 to 1 50.56% 1 contract, $112.50 at risk
34.00 34.50 34.00 0.99 to 1 50.36% 0 contracts, $172.50 is over budget

A bigger spinning top moves the ratio toward 1 to 1 and never crosses it. The break even win rate stays above 50% before commissions and slippage, which push it higher. Bulkowski's spinning top reversal rates of 50% and 51% do not clear that bar.

So a spinning top bracket trade with a measured-move target is priced to lose slowly unless your own records show an edge. Better options are to use the spinning top as a level and plan the trade from the breakout bar, or to target a prior swing high or low that sits further away than the bar's height.

Exit rules for marubozu and spinning top trades

For exits on either candle, write them before entry. A fixed target, a measured move, a prior swing level, or a trailing stop after the first target are all valid. Moving the target after entry because the candle "looks strong" is not. That is usually hope talking, and it tends to show up right after a winning streak.

Related lesson: Risk reward ratio

A Worked Marubozu Trade Priced Four Ways

This illustrative marubozu example uses a strict bullish marubozu, the C1 bar with no shadows, on the Micro E-mini S&P 500. The bar runs from 7,000.00 to 7,036.00, a 36.00 point body and range. A prior swing low sits at 6,989.00. The measured-move target adds the bar height to the high, which gives 7,072.00. The risk budget is $125, which is 0.5% of an illustrative $25,000 account. The Micro E-mini is worth $5 per index point and $1.25 per tick.

Two entries and three stops produce four trades on the same signal:

Entry and stop Risk in points and ticks Reward in points and ticks Reward to risk Break even win rate Micro E-mini size on $125
Breakout at 7,036.50, stop 6,999.75 under the low 36.75 points, 147 ticks 35.50 points, 142 ticks 0.97 to 1 50.87% 0 contracts, $183.75 is over budget
Breakout at 7,036.50, stop 7,017.75 under the midpoint 18.75 points, 75 ticks 35.50 points, 142 ticks 1.89 to 1 34.56% 1 contract, $93.75 at risk, $177.50 target
Pullback at 7,018.00, stop 6,999.75 under the low 18.25 points, 73 ticks 54.00 points, 216 ticks 2.96 to 1 25.26% 1 contract, $91.25 at risk, $270.00 target
Pullback at 7,018.00, stop 6,988.75 under the swing low 29.25 points, 117 ticks 54.00 points, 216 ticks 1.85 to 1 35.14% 0 contracts, $146.25 is over budget

Reading the four marubozu entries

The first row is the trade many people take by default. Buying the breakout with the stop under the candle low risks 36.75 points to make 35.50. That is 0.97 to 1, and one Micro contract carries $183.75 of risk, 0.74% of the account. It does not fit the budget, and it pays less than it risks.

The second row keeps the breakout entry but tightens the stop to the midpoint. The ratio improves to 1.89 to 1, but the stop now sits inside the bar, where a normal pullback can reach it.

The third row is the one worth building a rule around. A limit at the midpoint with the stop under the candle low risks 18.25 points to make 54.00, which is 2.96 to 1 with a break even win rate of 25.26%. One Micro contract carries $91.25 of risk, 0.37% of the account.

The fourth row is the warning. Moving the stop out to the swing low costs $146.25 per contract, which breaks the budget. A patient entry does not rescue a stop placed too far away.

The pullback formula for any marubozu

For a strict marubozu of height h, a midpoint entry with the stop one tick under the far end and a measured-move target pays 1.5 times h against 0.5 times h plus one tick. On this 36.00 point bar that is 54.00 against 18.25. As the bar gets taller, the ratio approaches 3 to 1 without reaching it: about 2.82 to 1 on an 8.00 point bar and 2.99 to 1 on a 100.00 point bar.

The catch is that the pullback has to happen. On a strong momentum bar, price may never come back to the midpoint, and every missed fill is a winner you did not get. Log how often the retrace arrives before you rely on it.

Related lesson: Tick size and tick value

Position Sizing for Marubozu and Spinning Top Trades

Position sizing for marubozu and spinning top trades starts from the stop, never from the candle's appearance. A tall marubozu feels like a strong signal, and that feeling is exactly what tempts traders to size up on the trades with the widest stops.

The method is the same for either candle:

  1. Set a fixed risk per trade, such as 0.5% of the account. On an illustrative $25,000 account that is $125.
  2. Measure the stop distance in points from your planned entry.
  3. Convert points to dollars for the contract you actually trade. The E-mini S&P 500 is worth $50 per index point and the Micro E-mini S&P 500 is $5 per index point.
  4. Divide the budget by the dollar risk per contract and round down.

The instrument step is where the expensive mistakes happen. An 18.25 point stop under a marubozu is $91.25 on one Micro contract and $912.50 on one E-mini. Same chart, same candle, ten times the dollar risk.

If the stop does not fit even one contract, skip the trade or find a closer invalidation. Widening the budget "just this once" is how one candle turns into a bad week. Rounding down also means your actual risk is usually below the budget, which is fine.

Account rules matter too. A trailing drawdown or a daily loss limit turns a handful of oversized losses into a failed account before a pattern has had a fair test. Risk per trade is the one variable you fully control.

Related lesson: Position sizing

How Marubozu and Spinning Top Candles Behave Across Timeframes

Marubozu and spinning top candles behave very differently by timeframe, and this guide's own illustrative count on E-mini S&P 500 futures shows why.

The method: continuous front-month ES bars from Yahoo Finance, read on November 4, 2026. Daily bars covered 503 sessions from November 5, 2024 to November 4, 2026. Five-minute bars covered regular hours (9:30 AM to 4:00 PM ET) from August 27, 2026 to November 4, 2026, 3,819 bars after removing two bars over 50 points as possible data errors. Each bar was classified with this guide's range test: marubozu tolerances of 0%, 2% and 5% of range, a spinning top body of 5% to 30% with shadows at least 20% and within 15 points, and bodies under 5% sent to the doji family. This is a small descriptive count, not a trading backtest.

Measure Daily ES bars Five-minute ES bars
Median bar range 77.00 points 5.50 points
Marubozu at 0% tolerance 0 bars 13 bars, 0.34%
Marubozu at 2% tolerance 0 bars 20 bars, 0.52%
Marubozu at 5% tolerance 2 bars, 0.40% 60 bars, 1.57%
Spinning tops 37 bars, 7.36% 273 bars, 7.15%
Spinning tops that broke out with the prior 5-bar move 17 126
Spinning tops that broke out against the prior 5-bar move 20 128

What the ES timeframe count shows about each candle

Three things stand out in this guide's ES count of daily and five-minute marubozu and spinning top candles.

First, a true marubozu almost never prints on a daily ES chart. Not one daily bar in two years passed a 2% tolerance, and only 2 passed at 5%. On a 77.00 point median range, some pushback before the close is nearly certain. On five-minute bars, small ranges make shadow-free bars more common, partly because a few ticks of travel can round to zero shadow. A five-minute marubozu is a smaller claim than a daily one.

Second, spinning tops are common on both timeframes, about 7% of bars, and their breakouts split almost evenly. On five-minute bars, 126 broke out with the prior move and 128 against it. That matches Bulkowski's 50% and 51% reversal rates on stocks, and it is why a spinning top is better read as a level than as a directional signal.

Third, the marubozu pullback is not guaranteed. In this guide's count, of the 60 five-minute marubozu bars at 5% tolerance, price returned to the midpoint within 12 bars on 45 of them, 75.00%. Of the 45 fills, 44 resolved the same session: 13 reached the measured-move target first and 31 hit the stop first, a 29.55% hit rate against a break even near 26.15% on the median 8.00 point bar. That sample is far too small to call an edge. It shows why you count fills and outcomes yourself before trusting any rule.

Higher timeframes produce fewer signals with stops that cost more in dollars. A 30 point daily stop is $1,500 on one E-mini. Lower timeframes produce more signals with less information in each. Many day traders mark levels and context on a higher timeframe and take the candle trigger on a lower one.

Trading marubozu and spinning top candles on intraday futures accounts

On our accounts, every position has to be closed by 4:45 PM ET on regular trading days, with no overnight or weekend holds, so a daily marubozu or spinning top is context and any trade off it happens intraday. Our 50K accounts allow up to 4 minis or 40 micros, which is why sizing marubozu and spinning top trades in Micro contracts matters. WealthCharts on our accounts includes Chart Replay for practising candle reads on past sessions, and all evaluation and funded accounts are simulated.

Related lesson: Multiple timeframe analysis

Common Marubozu and Spinning Top Mistakes

Marubozu and spinning top mistakes repeat in recognisable forms, and most of them come from deciding after the bar instead of before it.

Mistake What it looks like Why it costs money The fix
Tolerance drift Accepting a bar with a 1.37% shadow one day and rejecting the same shape the next The pattern is defined by the chart you want to trade, not by a rule Write the shadow tolerance as a share of range and keep it for a full sample
Breakout by default Buying beyond a marubozu high with the stop under its low The stop sits outside the range the entry already cleared, so the ratio lands under 1 to 1 Price the breakout and the pullback before choosing
Spinning top as a breakout bracket Entering beyond a spinning top's high with a target equal to its range Reward is the range and risk is wider, so the trade cannot pay 1 to 1 Treat the bar as a level and plan the trade from the breakout bar
Unbalanced shadows called a spinning top A small body with one long shadow and one short It is a rejection candle with directional information Require both shadows over 20% and within 15 points of each other
Doji read as a spinning top A body under 5% of range A doji has no real body, so it belongs to a different family Run the doji test before the spinning top test
Wrong instrument math Sizing an ES position from a chart read in Micro terms The E-mini carries ten times the dollar risk per point Convert the stop to dollars on the contract you trade
Pattern found after the decision Spotting a marubozu that supports a trade you already wanted Both candles are common enough that a search always succeeds Qualify the candle before the entry exists, not after

The two costliest marubozu and spinning top mistakes

Tolerance drift and breakout by default cost the most among marubozu and spinning top errors, because neither feels like a mistake at the time. The first hides in the definition. The second hides in the fact that buying the breakout feels like the confident choice.

Related lesson: How to keep a trading journal

What Research Says About Marubozu and Spinning Top Reliability

Research on marubozu and spinning top reliability is less flattering than most pattern guides suggest.

Bulkowski's statistics at ThePatternSite rank 103 candlestick patterns, where 1 is the best performer after the breakout:

Candle Tested behaviour Frequency rank Overall performance rank
White marubozu Continuation 56% of the time 27 71
Black marubozu Continuation 53% of the time 30 57
Closing white marubozu Continuation 55% of the time 15 70
Opening white marubozu Continuation 54% of the time 7 75
Closing black marubozu Continuation 52% of the time 18 43
White spinning top Reversal 50% of the time 2 69
Black spinning top Reversal 51% of the time 1 73

The spinning tops are among the most frequent candles in the catalogue and in the bottom half for performance. Bulkowski writes that marubozu candles have been given more weight by candlestick followers than he thinks they deserve.

Academic tests of marubozu and spinning top candles

Academic tests of candlestick patterns point the same way as Bulkowski's figures. Marshall, Young and Rose (Journal of Banking and Finance, 2006) tested candlestick patterns on Dow Jones Industrial Average stocks from 1992 to 2002 with a bootstrap method built for open, high, low and close data, and found no forecasting power. Tharavanij, Siraprapasiri and Rajchamaha (SAGE Open, 2017) tested the SET50 stocks in Thailand from July 3, 2006 to June 30, 2016, including all six marubozu variants. They found the mean returns of most patterns were not statistically different from zero, and even the significant ones carried high standard deviations.

One result in the Tharavanij SET50 study points the other way. The opening white marubozu returned a mean of 0.71% over 10 days under a fixed-exit rule, statistically significant, but with a standard deviation of 8.04%. A small average edge inside that much spread is hard to trade.

None of this makes the candles useless. It makes them a description of who controlled a bar and a place to hang an invalidation, which is a smaller claim than the one usually attached to them.

Marubozu and Spinning Top Candles FAQ

What does a marubozu candle indicate?

A marubozu indicates that one side controlled the bar from open to close. A bullish marubozu opens at or near the low and closes at or near the high, and a bearish one is the reverse. It does not promise the next bar continues, and Bulkowski found the white marubozu continued 56% of the time.

What is a spinning top?

A spinning top is a candle with a small body and shadows on both sides that are roughly balanced. Price travelled both ways and closed near the open, so neither side won the bar. Its meaning comes from where it prints, such as at support or resistance or after a long move.

What is a wave candle?

A wave candle usually means a high wave spinning top: a small body with unusually long upper and lower shadows. It shows wide two-way travel that ended near the open. Read it like a spinning top, as indecision at a level rather than a directional signal.

Is a red candle bullish or bearish?

A red candle is bearish for that bar, because it closed below its open. How much that matters depends on shape and location. A red marubozu shows sellers in full control, while a red spinning top shows a standoff where sellers only edged the close.

What is the difference between a marubozu and a spinning top?

They sit at opposite ends of the body-to-range measurement. A marubozu's body fills nearly the whole range with almost no shadows, while a spinning top has a small body with long shadows on both sides. The trades differ too, because a marubozu offers a clear invalidation and a spinning top mostly offers a level.

Can a spinning top be a doji?

Not under a rule that requires a visible body. A doji has an open and close that are equal or nearly equal, usually a body under about 5% of range. A spinning top carries a small but real body, commonly capped at about 30% of range.

What is the best timeframe for marubozu and spinning top candles?

There is no measured best timeframe. Daily bars produce fewer, more meaningful candles with wider stops, while intraday bars produce many more with less information in each. A common approach is to read context on a higher timeframe and time the entry on a lower one.

Risk Note for Trading Marubozu and Spinning Top Candles

Trading futures involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone, and leverage means a single trade can lose more than you expect. Stop orders do not guarantee your exit price, and fast markets can fill well beyond the level you set. Every price, bar, account figure and position size in this guide is an illustrative example, and the ES count is a small descriptive study, not a record of real trades or a promise of any result. Evaluation and funded prop firm accounts are simulated, and simulated results do not represent live trading. This guide is general education, not investment advice.